Skip to content
FindYourPizza

Pizza Without Tomato Sauce

Tomato sauce is the default, not a rule. Plenty of classic pizzas skip it: the white clam pie of New Haven is built on garlic and olive oil, Alsatian flammkuchen uses crème fraîche, and pizza bianca in Rome is little more than dough, oil and salt. Whether you're avoiding tomatoes or just want a change, the sauce you pick decides what the rest of the pizza should be.

Taking out the tomato also takes out the pizza's main source of acid and much of its moisture. Cream and cheese sauces make the pie richer, so they want something sharp on top: lemon, capers, pickled onions, arugula or a bitter green. Oil bases let the toppings speak and crisp the crust. Pestos and herb sauces bring their own brightness but lose color and freshness in a long, hot bake.

Below is every non-tomato sauce in our catalog, with the toppings it pairs with most strongly in our data. We left out tomato-based sauces, including vodka sauce, tikka masala sauce, romesco (traditionally made with roasted tomatoes) and most barbecue sauce, which is usually built on tomato or ketchup.

An example pizza Potatoes & Parmigiano-Reggiano Open it in the generator

What's on it

After the bake
Fresh Basil

How to make it

  1. Make a Neapolitan dough ahead of time. PizzaLogic scales it to your oven and schedule.
  2. Heat a pizza oven to 800–900°F. In a home oven, preheat a steel on the top rack at max heat for an hour and use the broiler.
  3. Stretch the dough by hand, keeping the edge thicker than the middle.
  4. Spread the garlic oil thinly, leaving the rim bare.
  5. Add the Buffalo mozzarella, torn and patted dry so it doesn't pool.
  6. Spread potatoes and fresh rosemary evenly to the edges, without piling them in the middle.
  7. Bake for 60–90 seconds, until the crust is deeply browned and the cheese is bubbling.
  8. After the bake, add Parmigiano-Reggiano and fresh basil.
  9. Let it rest a minute, then slice and serve.

Sauces, and what goes with each

Oil, cream and cheese bases

Garlic oil is the simplest swap: olive oil warmed with garlic, brushed thin. It suits clams, potatoes, broccoli rabe and bitter greens, and it lets the crust crisp more than a wet sauce does. Keep the garlic sliced or grated rather than in large pieces, which can scorch on a very hot pie.

Béchamel, onion mornay and truffle cream are richer and more forgiving. Spread them thinner than you would tomato sauce, since they thicken and brown in the oven, and pair them with fontina, mushrooms, potatoes or ham. Crème fraîche bakes into a tangy film rather than a thick layer, which is why it works under bacon and onion on flammkuchen. All of these need an acidic or bitter topping to keep the pizza from tasting heavy.

Pestos, purées and bolder bases

Basil and pistachio pesto keep their color and fresh flavor best if added after baking or in the last minute or two; baked from the start, basil darkens and the flavor goes flat. Chimichurri works the same way. Squash or pumpkin purée is a sweet, autumnal base that pairs with sage, sausage and hazelnuts, and mushroom ragù makes a deep, savory one.

For heat, gochujang, harissa and buffalo sauce all bake into strong, spicy bases; use them thinly, since they're concentrated, and add something cooling after the bake such as ranch, crème fraîche, yogurt or fresh herbs. Harissa is a chili paste and is tomato-free in its traditional form, but some jarred versions add tomato, so check the label if you're avoiding it. Tomatillo salsa is made from a different plant (a husked relative of the tomato) and gives a sharp, green base that suits pork and chiles.

Build your own

We've started you off with the essentials. Change anything, or just build.

Questions

What can I use instead of tomato sauce on pizza?

Garlic olive oil, béchamel or another white sauce, pesto, crème fraîche, ricotta, squash purée, and chili pastes like gochujang or harissa all work. The choice depends on your toppings: oil for seafood and greens, cream sauces for mushrooms and potatoes, pesto for fresh vegetables and mozzarella.

What is a pizza without tomato sauce called?

In the US it's usually called a white pizza, and in Italy a pizza bianca. Both terms can mean very different things, from a cheese-and-ricotta pie to plain dough with olive oil and salt.

Is BBQ sauce a good substitute for tomato sauce?

It's a different flavor, but not a tomato-free one: most barbecue sauces are built on tomato or ketchup. If you're avoiding tomatoes, check the label or use a mustard- or vinegar-based barbecue sauce instead.

Does pizza without sauce get dry?

Not if you use some fat. Brush the dough with olive oil or a thin layer of a white sauce, use a good melting cheese, and add moist toppings like ricotta or roasted vegetables. A drizzle of oil or a spoonful of pesto after baking also helps.

More pizzas