Cremini Mushrooms on Pizza
The workhorse pizza mushroom — mild, firm, and earthy, sliced thin for even browning across the pie.
earthy, umami · baked on · Vegetarian, Vegan, Pescatarian, Dairy-free, Gluten-free toppings, Nut-free, No pork, Halal-friendly
Cremini Mushrooms is a mushroom that brings earthy and umami notes and bakes on with the pizza.
Recipe data backs up its classic partners: fresh thyme, truffle oil and plant-based pepperoni appear alongside cremini mushrooms far more often than chance would predict. The less obvious partner is refried beans: the two share 139 flavor compounds but rarely meet in recipes.
It's a signature of Chicago Deep-Dish pizza. It's vegan and contains no gluten.
Full guide: Mushroom Pizza, with an example pizza, how to make it and common questions.
Build a pizza around cremini mushrooms
What goes with cremini mushrooms on pizza
Proven in recipes or on pizzeria menus.
- Fresh Thymeherb Cooked together often: top 25% of recipe pairings
- Truffle Oildrizzle Cooked together often: top 10% of recipe pairings
- Fontinacheese A pizzeria pairing
- Plant-Based Pepperoniplant-based Cooked together often: top 25% of recipe pairings
- Onion Mornaysauce A pizzeria pairing
- Spinachvegetable A pizzeria pairing
- Caramelized Onionsvegetable A pizzeria pairing
- White Onionvegetable A pizzeria pairing
- Bell Peppersvegetable A pizzeria pairing
- Brown Gravysauce A pizzeria pairing
- Truffle Creamsauce A pizzeria pairing
- Vegan Mozzarellacheese A pizzeria pairing
Surprising cremini mushrooms pairings
Rarely cooked together, but chemically close. Worth a try.
- Refried Beanssauce 139 shared flavor compounds
Shares aromas with cremini mushrooms
Lots of flavor compounds in common.
- Gochujang Saucesauce 149 shared flavor compounds
- Potatoesvegetable 151 shared flavor compounds
- French Friespotato 151 shared flavor compounds
- Mashed Potatoespotato 151 shared flavor compounds
- San Marzano Tomatosauce 149 shared flavor compounds
- Doctored Red Saucesauce 149 shared flavor compounds
What to use instead of cremini mushrooms
Ingredients that play a similar role in recipes.
Pizzas to try with cremini mushrooms
- New York-Style Cremini Mushrooms & Italian Sausage Doctored Red Sauce, Low-Moisture Mozzarella, Cremini Mushrooms, Italian Sausage, Pepperoni (Cupping), Dried Oregano, Red Pepper Flakes
- Neapolitan Roasted Cherry Tomatoes & Cremini Mushrooms Basil Pesto, Burrata, Cremini Mushrooms, Roasted Cherry Tomatoes, Fresh Thyme, Fresh Basil
A signature of Chicago Deep-Dish pizza.
Guides: Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza