Skip to content
FindYourPizza

Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza

Pepperoni and mushroom is a standard two-topping order in American pizzerias. Pepperoni is spicy, salty and fatty; mushrooms are earthy and meaty, with a sponge-like structure. As the pizza bakes, the pepperoni renders its paprika-red fat, and the mushrooms soak it up. You end up with mushrooms that taste seasoned and pepperoni that doesn't taste greasy.

Cremini are a brown variety of the same species as white button mushrooms, with a firmer texture and deeper flavor. They brown well and hold their shape, which makes them the better pick for this pizza.

An example pizza Cremini Mushrooms & Pepperoni Open it in the generator

What's on this Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza

After the bake
Red Pepper Flakes

How to make Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza

  1. Make a New York dough ahead of time. PizzaLogic scales it to your oven and schedule.
  2. Heat the oven to 550°F with a pizza steel or stone inside.
  3. Stretch the dough by hand, keeping the edge thicker than the middle.
  4. Spread the doctored red sauce thinly, leaving the rim bare.
  5. Add the low-moisture mozzarella.
  6. Spread pepperoni and cremini mushrooms evenly to the edges, without piling them in the middle.
  7. Bake for 12–15 minutes, until the crust is deeply browned and the cheese is bubbling.
  8. After the bake, add red pepper flakes.
  9. Let it rest a minute, then slice and serve.

Why pepperoni and cremini mushrooms work, in data

Also goes with both

Keep the mushrooms from going watery

Mushrooms are mostly water. Sliced raw and thin, they'll cook on a hot pizza, but they release liquid that can pool on the cheese. For a better result, sauté the slices in a hot pan with a little oil and salt until they've given up their water and started to brown, about 5 to 8 minutes. They'll take on more color and flavor.

Put the mushrooms on first and the pepperoni on top. That way the pepperoni crisps and cups, and its fat drips down onto the mushrooms during the bake.

Build your own Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza

We've started you off with the essentials. Change anything, or just build.

Questions about Pepperoni and Mushroom Pizza

Should I cook mushrooms before putting them on pizza?

It helps. Raw mushrooms release water while they bake. Sautéing them first drives off that water and adds browned flavor. If you use them raw, slice them very thin.

Which mushrooms are best with pepperoni?

Cremini are the best all-rounder. White button mushrooms are milder, and shiitake or oyster mushrooms bring more savory depth.

What else goes with pepperoni and mushroom?

Italian sausage, bell peppers, onions or black olives turn it toward a supreme. Provolone mixed with the mozzarella adds sharpness.

More pizzas