Skip to content
FindYourPizza

Jalapeño Popper Pizza

Jalapeño poppers are jalapeños stuffed with cream cheese, usually with cheddar, then wrapped in bacon or breaded and baked or fried. A jalapeño popper pizza keeps every part: cream cheese and cheddar for the filling, sliced jalapeños, crisp bacon, and a crunchy breadcrumb topping that stands in for the breading.

The combination works because each part covers for another. Cream cheese is cool, tangy and rich, which softens the jalapeño's heat; bacon adds salt and smoke; the green, grassy flavor of the pepper keeps all that dairy from feeling heavy. Pickled jalapeños add a sour bite that fresh ones don't.

The generator below always includes cream cheese, fresh jalapeños, bacon and cheddar. The example adds toasted breadcrumbs after the bake for the popper crunch.

An example pizza Jalapeño Popper Pizza Open it in the generator

What's on this Jalapeño Popper Pizza

How to make Jalapeño Popper Pizza

  1. Make a New York dough ahead of time. PizzaLogic scales it to your oven and schedule.
  2. Heat the oven to 550°F with a pizza steel or stone inside.
  3. Stretch the dough by hand, keeping the edge thicker than the middle.
  4. Spread the garlic oil thinly, leaving the rim bare.
  5. Add the cheddar.
  6. Spread fresh jalapeños and bacon evenly to the edges, without piling them in the middle.
  7. Finish with cream cheese.
  8. Bake for 12–15 minutes, until the crust is deeply browned and the cheese is bubbling.
  9. After the bake, add pangrattato.
  10. Let it rest a minute, then slice and serve.

What goes on a Jalapeño Popper Pizza

How to build it

Soften the cream cheese and either dollop it over the pizza in small spoonfuls or stir in a little garlic and grated cheddar and spread it thinly as the base. Dollops stay creamy and give you pockets of filling; a spread base gives an even popper flavor in every bite. Either way, use less than you think: cream cheese doesn't melt and spread the way mozzarella does.

Cook the bacon most of the way before topping, then crumble or chop it. Slice the jalapeños into thin rings so they soften in the bake. Cover with shredded cheddar, or a cheddar and mozzarella mix if you want more stretch.

Add the crunch at the end. Toasted breadcrumbs or panko tossed with a little butter or oil, scattered over the hot pizza, gives the texture of a breaded popper. Added before baking, they'll either burn or go soft under the cheese.

Controlling the heat

Most of a jalapeño's heat is in the white ribs and seeds. Scrape them out for a mild pizza, or leave some in for more kick. Heat varies a lot from pepper to pepper, so taste a slice of each before topping. Pickled jalapeños are usually milder and add acidity; using some of each gives you both heat and tang.

A drizzle of hot honey after the bake is a common addition; a little sweetness against the heat and the creamy filling suits it well.

Variations

Adding chicken turns it into a more filling main course. Swapping the bacon for crumbled breakfast sausage gives a version closer to sausage-stuffed poppers. A crust in the Detroit style suits the rich, heavy toppings, and the cheddar against the pan walls crisps into a cheese edge that matches the bacon's crunch.

Build your own Jalapeño Popper Pizza

The generator is set to Jalapeño Popper Pizza: the essentials are always on it, the rest changes each time.

Questions about Jalapeño Popper Pizza

What goes on a jalapeño popper pizza?

Cream cheese, cheddar, bacon and sliced jalapeños, usually on a garlic or white base, often with a crunchy breadcrumb or panko topping added after baking. Many versions include both fresh and pickled jalapeños, plus green onion.

What sauce goes on jalapeño popper pizza?

Most versions skip tomato. The base is usually garlic oil, a garlic white sauce, or the cream cheese itself mixed with a little garlic and cheddar and spread thinly. Ranch or hot honey are popular drizzles after the bake.

How do you make jalapeño popper pizza less spicy?

Remove the seeds and white ribs from the jalapeños, which hold most of the heat, and use more cream cheese relative to pepper. Pickled jalapeños are usually milder than fresh ones. You can also slice the peppers thicker so there are fewer pieces per bite.

Does cream cheese melt on pizza?

It softens and warms but doesn't melt and stretch like mozzarella. Spoon it on in small dollops or spread it thinly, and pair it with a melting cheese such as cheddar or mozzarella to hold the toppings together.

More pizzas