Skip to content
FindYourPizza

The Best Cheese for Pizza

The best pizza cheese melts smoothly, stretches, browns in spots and doesn't flood the crust with water or oil. Three things decide how a cheese behaves in the oven: moisture, fat and age. Young, moist cheeses melt soft but release water. Drier cheeses brown and blister more. Long-aged cheeses have a protein structure that aging has broken down, so they soften and sweat fat instead of stretching into a smooth layer.

That's why most pizza is built on a base cheese, the one that melts across the whole pie, plus an accent cheese used in small amounts for flavor. Low-moisture mozzarella is the default base for good reasons, but fontina, provolone and others melt well too. Aged and crumbly cheeses like Parmigiano-Reggiano, Pecorino Romano, feta and cotija work best as accents, often added after the bake.

Below, every cheese in our catalog is sorted into base and accent cheeses, ranked by how strongly it is tied to pizza in recipe data.

An example pizza NY Slice with Doctored Red Sauce & Dried Oregano Open it in the generator

What's on it

Toppings
Dried Oregano
After the bake
Red Pepper Flakes

How to make it

  1. Make a New York dough ahead of time. PizzaLogic scales it to your oven and schedule.
  2. Heat the oven to 550°F with a pizza steel or stone inside.
  3. Stretch the dough by hand, keeping the edge thicker than the middle.
  4. Spread the doctored red sauce thinly, leaving the rim bare.
  5. Add the low-moisture mozzarella and provolone.
  6. Spread dried oregano evenly to the edges, without piling them in the middle.
  7. Bake for 12–15 minutes, until the crust is deeply browned and the cheese is bubbling.
  8. After the bake, add red pepper flakes.
  9. Let it rest a minute, then slice and serve.

Melting cheeses

The base layer. Ordered by how often each shows up on pizza.

CheeseMoistureFlavorWhat it does
Fior di Latte High (fresh) creamy, sweet Fresh cow's-milk mozzarella with a delicate, milky sweetness that melts into silky pools.
Buffalo Mozzarella High (fresh) creamy, tangy, rich Lush water-buffalo mozzarella with a richer tang and creamier bite than cow's-milk versions.
Burrata High (fresh) creamy, rich, sweet A pouch of mozzarella filled with stracciatella cream, split open post-bake for maximum indulgence.
Low-Moisture Mozzarella Low salty, creamy The classic pizza cheese — aged to reduce moisture for superior browning and stretchy pull.
Fontina Low nutty, earthy, creamy Nutty, buttery Alpine cheese that melts beautifully and pairs with earthy, rich toppings.
Smoked Mozzarella (Scamorza) Low smoky, creamy, rich Naturally smoked mozzarella with a golden rind and a woodsy, campfire-like depth.
Stracciatella High (fresh) creamy, rich, sweet Shreds of mozzarella soaked in cream, spooned on after the bake so cool milky ribbons melt into the hot crust.
Oaxaca Cheese (Quesillo) Low creamy, salty, tangy Mexican string cheese wound into balls - melts like mozzarella with a saltier, buttery tang.
Provolone Low tangy, salty, rich Semi-hard Italian cheese with a sharp, slightly smoky tang that complements bold toppings.
Caciocavallo Low nutty, salty, tangy, rich Aged gourd-shaped pasta filata that melts glossy and stretchy with a sharper, nuttier bite than mozzarella.
Monterey Jack Low creamy, rich, salty Mild, buttery California cheese that melts smooth and even - the easygoing partner for taco, chicken, and chorizo pies.
Ricotta High (fresh) creamy, sweet Light, fluffy whey cheese dolloped in clouds that add milky sweetness and textural contrast.
Smoked Gouda Low smoky, creamy, nutty Creamy, campfire-smoked Dutch-style cheese that melts smoothly and doubles down on barbecue and bacon flavors.
Pepper Jack Low spicy, creamy, salty Monterey Jack studded with spicy peppers that melts into gooey, fiery pockets across the pizza.
Wisconsin Brick Cheese Low creamy, tangy, salty Buttery, high-fat Wisconsin cheese cubed to the pan edges, where it fries into a lacy, caramelized frico crown.
Cheddar Low tangy, salty, rich Sharp, tangy aged cheddar that adds bold flavor and a golden, crispy edge when baked.
Gruyère Low nutty, sweet, rich Nutty, complex Alpine cheese with a superior melt that forms a golden, lacy crust when baked.
Vegan Mozzarella Low creamy, salty Plant-based shreds, mostly coconut oil and starch, that melt and stretch like low-moisture mozzarella - check labels, since some brands are cashew-based.
Swiss (Emmental) Low nutty, sweet, creamy Holey, nutty-sweet Emmental that melts into a glossy blanket, the cheese a Reuben pizza can't do without.

Accent cheeses

Used in small amounts for flavor: dolloped, crumbled or grated over the top.

CheeseWhenFlavorWhat it does
Taleggio Baked on funky, creamy, tangy, rich Pungent Italian washed-rind cheese that melts into aromatic pools, perfect with earthy mushrooms and cured meats.
Gorgonzola Baked on funky, salty, creamy, pungent Italian blue cheese with a sharp, tangy bite that adds pungent complexity in small amounts.
Goat Cheese Baked on tangy, creamy, earthy Tangy, creamy chèvre that crumbles and softens in the oven, pairing with sweet and earthy toppings.
Parmigiano-Reggiano After the bake umami, salty, nutty The king of cheeses — aged, crystalline, and bursting with umami, grated over the finished pie.
Asiago Baked on nutty, salty, tangy Semi-aged Veneto cheese that browns well and adds a nutty, salty edge to blends of milder melting cheeses.
Pecorino Romano After the bake salty, tangy, pungent Sharp, salty sheep's-milk cheese grated as a finishing accent for assertive, punchy flavor.
Manchego Baked on nutty, tangy, sweet Spanish sheep's-milk cheese with a buttery, nutty character that adds Old-World depth.
Feta Baked on tangy, salty, briny Briny, crumbly Greek cheese that softens in the oven and brightens Mediterranean-style pies.
Mascarpone Baked on creamy, sweet, rich Velvety Italian cream cheese that adds luscious richness to dessert pizzas and balances sharp flavors on savory pies.
Robiola Baked on creamy, tangy, earthy Soft, young Piedmontese cheese that slumps into tangy, mushroomy pools - made for truffle and wild mushrooms.
Paneer Baked on creamy, sweet Fresh acid-set cheese that holds its cubes in the oven, charring at the edges and soaking up tikka spices.
Cotija After the bake salty, tangy Dry, salty Mexican crumbles that don't melt - showered on after baking like a Latin answer to Parmigiano.
Brie Baked on creamy, rich, earthy Soft-ripened French cheese that melts into buttery, mushroomy puddles; best with fruit, honey, and cured ham.
Cream Cheese Baked on creamy, tangy, rich Savory, tangy cream cheese baked on in dollops that turn warm and spreadable - the heart of crab rangoon, jalapeño popper, and spinach-artichoke pies.

Why low-moisture mozzarella wins most of the time

Low-moisture mozzarella is mozzarella that has been aged and dried so it holds less water than fresh mozzarella. That gives it a long, even melt, a good stretch and enough dryness to brown at normal home-oven temperatures without leaving puddles. It's the standard cheese on New York, Detroit and most American pizza. Whole-milk versions melt richer and creamier than part-skim, which can turn rubbery.

Buy it in a block and shred it yourself if you can. Pre-shredded cheese is coated with anti-caking starch or cellulose so the shreds don't stick together, and that coating can make the melt less smooth. Cold cheese also shreds more cleanly than warm.

Fresh mozzarella, burrata and the wet cheeses

Fresh mozzarella (fior di latte or buffalo) melts into soft, milky pools, and it's the right cheese for a margherita, but it carries a lot of water. Tear or slice it, drain it on paper towels for 15 to 30 minutes, and use less than you'd use of shredded cheese. In a very hot oven it barely has time to weep; in a home oven at 500°F, some cooks add it partway through the bake so it melts without releasing water into the center.

Burrata and stracciatella are better after the bake. Spoon them on hot from the oven so the cream stays cool and fresh against the crust. Ricotta can go on before baking in dollops, where it sets and lightly browns, or after for a creamier result.

Browning, blends and accent cheeses

Browning comes from the Maillard reaction between cheese proteins and the small amount of sugar left in the cheese, helped along as water evaporates. Blisters form when steam lifts small domes in the cheese and their thin tops dry out and brown first. Drier cheeses tend to brown sooner, and a mozzarella-provolone blend (a common New York choice) browns more and tastes sharper than mozzarella alone. Fontina and Gruyère melt very smoothly and add nutty flavor; cheddar browns well but can turn oily at high heat, so blend it rather than use it alone.

Accent cheeses do their best work in small amounts. Parmigiano-Reggiano and Pecorino Romano add salt and savory depth; grate them over right before or right after baking, since a heavy baked layer turns dry and grainy. Gorgonzola, goat cheese and taleggio melt into pungent pockets, so dot them rather than spread them. Feta, paneer and cotija soften but hold their shape, which is useful when you want salty bites rather than a melted blanket.

Build your own

We've started you off with the essentials. Change anything, or just build.

Questions

What cheese do most pizzerias use?

Most American pizzerias use low-moisture mozzarella, often whole-milk, sometimes blended with provolone. Neapolitan-style pizzerias use fresh mozzarella, either fior di latte from cow's milk or mozzarella di bufala. Detroit-style pizza traditionally uses Wisconsin brick cheese.

Why is my pizza cheese greasy?

Higher-fat and aged cheeses like cheddar and some provolones release fat as they melt, and pepperoni adds more. Blend fattier cheeses with mozzarella, bake hot and fast rather than long and slow, and blot any pooled oil with a paper towel. Some pooling is normal on a pepperoni pie.

Can I use fresh mozzarella in a home oven?

Yes. Drain it well first, use less than you would shredded cheese, and get your oven and stone or steel as hot as they go. Adding it partway through the bake also helps keep the center from getting wet.

Is Parmesan good on pizza?

As an accent, yes. Parmigiano-Reggiano doesn't melt into a smooth, stretchy layer, but a light grating before or after the bake adds salt and savory depth. Note that traditional Parmigiano-Reggiano is made with animal rennet, so it isn't strictly vegetarian.

What is the best cheese blend for pizza?

Low-moisture mozzarella with some provolone is the most common blend. Mozzarella with a little fontina makes a creamier, nuttier melt, and a final grating of Parmigiano or Pecorino adds sharpness. Keep the melting cheese as the majority so the blend still stretches.

More pizzas